Virginia Regulatory Town Hall
Agency
Virginia Alcoholic Beverage Control Authority
 
Board
Virginia Alcoholic Beverage Control Board of Directors
 
chapter
Advertising [3 VAC 5 ‑ 20]
Action Updating Advertising Regulations as a Result of Periodic Review
Stage NOIRA
Comment Period Ended on 8/29/2012
spacer

15 comments

All comments for this forum
Back to List of Comments
8/22/12  3:26 pm
Commenter: Marilyn Turner, concerned individual

Objection to redeemable coupons, increasing dollar amount of movelties and allowing contributions
 
 To allow instantly redeemable coupons - I oppose this change because it will encourage spontaneous purchases of greater quantities of alcohol and can lead to excessive drinking.

Increasing the dollar amount of giveaways from $10 to $20 wholesale - the increased value of $20 wholesale exceeds a reasonable limit for a "novelty" and may be considered an expensive incentive to buy the alcohol brand promoted. I am concerned that these items can be distributed at athletic events which are often attended by youth.

Allowing contributions of alcohol to charitable events - if alcohol served must be purchased by the charity, less alcohol will be served than if they get it for free. I am also concerned that carding at these events may not be well controlled with untrained alcohol servers and and it is difficult to be aware of the age of the drink recipients at a charitable event.




CommentID: 23790
 

8/22/12  8:46 pm
Commenter: Katherine Ott Walter

Coupons on Alcoholic Beverages
 

I oppose the recommendation to allow coupons on alcoholic beverages. Research has repeatedly shown that one of the only things that decreased overall alcohol consumption is price increase. To allow citizens to use coupons would go against everything the research suggests to reduce drinking, especially among college students who regularly consume at a high-risk level and drink to get drunk.

CommentID: 23791
 

8/22/12  10:35 pm
Commenter: Susan Bruce

Do not allow instantly redeemable manufacturer coupons.
 

Studies show that when the price of alcohol increases, there are reductions in motor vehicle crashes and fatalities, alcohol-impaired driving, violence and deaths.  Alcohol consumption increases when the price is lowered and this is particularly true for youths. Do not lower the price of alcohol by allowing manufacturer coupons.

CommentID: 23793
 

8/23/12  11:25 am
Commenter: Kathy Graham Sullivan-Director, Roanoke Area Youth Substance Abuse Coalitio

instantly redeemable manufacturer coupons
 
CommentID: 23795
 

8/23/12  12:11 pm
Commenter: Becky Johnston, Strong Families/Great Youth Coalition

Do not allow instantly redeemable manufacturer coupons
 

Do not allow instantly redeemable manufacturer coupons. Alcohol consumption is responsive to price. Studies showed higher alcohol prices were consistent with fewer motor vehicle crashes and fatalities, less alcohol-impaired driving, less violence and fewer deaths. Youth are particularly sensitive to price. Do not lower the price of alcohol by allowing manufacturer coupons.

CommentID: 23797
 

8/24/12  12:28 pm
Commenter: Linda Hancock

Instantly redeemable coupons and concerns about harm and increased cost to society
 

Research consistently demonstrates that as alcohol price goes down, harm goes up, and cost to society increases. Underage youth are those MOST sensitive to price reductions and they are also those who are the savviest about using the internet.

These facts suggest that instantly redeemable couponing and internet couponing would open the doors to increased consumption by underage drinkers. If couponing is allowed, coupons should ONLY be allowed at point of purchase where a sales clerk can perform an ID check.Internet coupons cannot possibly insure underage drinkers are restricted from those online sites. In addition the attraction of online couponing would open more avenues for direct electronic advertising to underage populations.
I am against couponing in any form, but if it is allowed every possible strategy to reduce harm should be incorporated in the regulations. For example, regulations should only allow print coupons at point of purchase and discount coupons should not exceed 10%. Fifty percent reductions are excessive and would seem to encourage overconsumption at any age thus increasing cost to taxpayers. Those wanting the regulations to be loosened should have to produce data that the proposed changes will not increase cost to society.
CommentID: 23802
 

8/28/12  9:51 am
Commenter: Randy Koch, concerned citizen

Couponing
 

Everyone knows, and the data proves, that when the cost of a product goes down, more people will buy it. This certainly applies to alcohol, especially when we're talking about young people. Discount coupons reduce the cost of alcohol, thus encouraging people to drink more. Why, when we already have a horrible problem with alcohol abuse and binge drinking would we want to encourage people to drink more. It's dangerous and it costs private business and the state millions of dollars each year to address the problems created by problem drinking. Please don't allow couponing.  

CommentID: 23830
 

8/28/12  10:29 am
Commenter: Wayne Frith; Substance Abuse Free Environment, Inc (SAFE)

Instantly redeemable coupons for reduced price alcohol
 

I oppose the recommendation to allow instantly redeemable coupons to reduce the price of alcoholic beverages. Research has repeatedly shown pricing has great elasticity relative to alcohol consumption. As prices for alcohol increase youthconsumption goes down especially among youth and problem drinkers. When the price goes down, consumption goes up. In other countries, happy hour and other price reduction strategies have been linked specifically to binge drinking and drunk driving. To allow citizens to use coupons to buy less expensive alcohol would go against everything the research suggests to reduce drinking, especially among college students who regularly consume at a high-risk level and drink to get drunk..

CommentID: 23831
 

8/28/12  5:42 pm
Commenter: Sharyl Adams

Manufacturer coupons for alcohol will result in greater harm
 

Instnatly redeemable manufacturer coupons mean cheaper alcohol. Cheaper alcohol means greater alcohol consumption. Lowering the price of alcohol through manufacturer coupons will increase alcohol-related harm, such as motor vehicle crashes, violence, injuries and death. Please do not permit manufacturers to issue coupons.

CommentID: 23843
 

8/29/12  10:30 am
Commenter: Erica Rollins

Don't Allow Redeemable Coupons
 

Research has shown that alcohol is responsive to price.  As the price goes up, consumption goes down.  When prices go up there are also less traffic crashes, DWIs, rapes and robberies, suicide and long-term health consequences.  Decreasing the cost of alcohol with redeemable coupons will decrease public safety and well-being.

CommentID: 23848
 

8/29/12  11:49 am
Commenter: Substance Abuse and Addiction Recovery Alliance (SAARA) of Virginia, Inc.

SAY NO TO COUPONS
 

Do not allow instantly redeemable manufacturer coupons. Alcohol consumption is responsive to price.  Studies showed higher alcohol prices were consistent with fewer motor vehicle crashes and fatalities, less alcohol-impaired driving,  less violence and fewer deaths.  Youth are particularly sensitive to price. Do not lower the price of alcohol by allowing manufacturer coupons

CommentID: 23849
 

8/29/12  3:18 pm
Commenter: Katherine Vatalaro Hill, Virginia Alcohol Policy Alliance

Manufacturer Instantly Redeemable Coupons
 

The Task Force on Community Preventive Services conducted a systematic review of scientific literature and determined that alcohol consumption is responsive to price.  As price goes up, alcohol consumption goes down. On average, alcohol consumption decreased almost 8% as price increased 10%. As consumption of alcohol decreased, so did alcohol-related harm. Higher alcohol prices were consistent with fewer motor vehicle crashes and fatalities, less alcohol-impaired driving, less violence and fewer deaths.  Some studies showed that youth (both underage and college age youth) were particularly sensitive to price of alcohol.  Higher alcohol prices were associated with less youth drinking.

 Due to this relationship between alcohol, price and related harm, we are very concerned about lowering alcohol prices through the use of manufacturer instantly redeemable coupons.  Based on the analysis of findings from these 73 studies, our fear is that as alcohol price goes down, alcohol consumption will increase as will alcohol-related harm.  To best protect the public, we suggest not allowing manufacturers to issue instantly redeemable coupons.  However, if the ABC wishes to implement this mechanism, we suggest only allowing a 10% reduction in price rather than 50% to mitigate the potential alcohol-related harm.  To minimize the impact of these instantly redeemable coupons we also suggest limiting the method of coupon delivery to print materials (print media or direct mail) and not on the Internet or electronic mail.

Guide to Community Preventive Services. Preventing excessive alcohol consumption: increasing alcohol taxes. www.thecommunityguide.org/alcohol/increasingtaxes.html. Accessed 8/13/2012.

CommentID: 23857
 

8/29/12  4:26 pm
Commenter: John Blair Reeves Citizen, father of 2 children& grandfather of 5(so far)

Va. ABC Regs.- Inadequate Benefits/ pros for more liquor coupons &/or related promotions
 

Do not allow instantly redeemable manufacturer coupons.

Per *many academic and U.S. Gov. studies plus practical and business sense:

1) Alcohol consumption is responsive to price. Studies showed higher alcohol prices were consistent with fewer motor vehicle crashes and fatalities, less alcohol-impaired driving, less violence and fewer deaths.

2)Youth are particularly sensitive to price.  And in Va., far too many youth now are harmed/ killed from DUIs/ incidents affected by alcohol impairment.

*Do not lower the price of alcohol by allowing manufacturer coupons.

* Too few Benefits/ Pros presented/ in the record, versus the hugh Costs/ Cons with this reg. proposal.

CommentID: 23866
 

8/29/12  4:47 pm
Commenter: John Blair Reeves citizen/ father of 2/ grandfather of 5 (so far)

Va. ABC Regs.-Inadequate Benefits/Pros for more liquor promotions/SWAG or alcohol "contributions"
 

These new rules would increase the maximum dollar value amount from $10 to $20 for give-away novelty and specialty items bearing alcoholic beverage advertising and allow contributions of alcoholic beverages to charitable groups (to be served) for service at events.

Again, per essential "due diligence", with Pros & Cons, for any such alcohol control or controlled substance regulation, the record shows very inadequate "Pros" here and too much focus on short-term profits for any sellers/ wholesalers involved.  Discard these proposals.

CommentID: 23868
 

8/29/12  7:33 pm
Commenter: Jeffrey Levy / Virginia College Parents, Inc.

Do not allow instantly redeemable manufacturer coupons.
 

Do not allow instantly redeemable manufacturer coupons. Alcohol consumption is responsive to price.  Studies showed higher alcohol prices were consistent with fewer motor vehicle crashes and fatalities, less alcohol-impaired driving,  less violence and fewer deaths.  Youth are particularly sensitive to price. Do not lower the price of alcohol by allowing manufacturer coupons.

CommentID: 23869