Virginia Regulatory Town Hall
Agency
Department of Education
 
Board
State Board of Education
 
Guidance Document Change: The 2020 Virginia General Assembly passed House Bill 753 directing the Virginia Department of Education (VDOE) to develop guidance standards for social emotional learning (SEL) for all public students in grades Kindergarten through 12 in the Commonwealth. The Virginia Social Emotional Learning Standards were developed in collaboration with an SEL Advisory Committee, composed of educators, community leaders, agency personnel, and parents. The Virginia SEL Standards are aligned with the Profile of a Virginia Graduate and centered in equity. This intentional focus allows the Standards to explicitly teach the skills needed to be “life ready” and to create more equitable learning environments.
Previous Comment     Next Comment     Back to List of Comments
5/6/21  8:54 am
Commenter: Howard Turner

Forced group identification is not the Virginia way
 

When read in full, the SEL draft standards show some promise, but are also disturbing. 

Forced group identification should be of grave concern to anyone truly interested in a diverse society.  As early as first grade, the draft standards require a child to identify groups in society and soon after, their place in these groups.  Who defines these groups? (the US census? visible differences? does the child self-identify?)  What makes a group?  There's no mention of race, religion, national origin, spoken language, physical abilities . . . what is unmentioned in the standards is more troubling that what is written.

I note the paucity of front-line educators on the implementation and advisory panels.

I respectfully request that the standards get a serious culling.  As a start, eliminate the group-based standards in all age bands (that's 18/20 of the appearance of the word "group") and the bias-based standards in all age bands (that's 7/8 appearances of the word "bias").  

Redirect the time and energy contemplated to implement these high-effort, low-benefit standards to real work to close the achievement gap.  Let's have real differentiated instruction in the classrooms.  Let's bring real measurement and data to the problem at hand.  Let's teach practical skills to prepare a workforce.  We need thinkers and doers, not children who have been taught what group they belong to.

When we group schoolchildren, it should be by their instructional requirements, academic interests, and career goals, not to further identity politics.

CommentID: 97961