Virginia Regulatory Town Hall
Agency
Department of Corrections
 
Board
State Board of Local and Regional Jails
 
chapter
Minimum Standards for Jails and Lockups [6 VAC 15 ‑ 40]
Action Amend current 6VAC15-40-770 to require that feminine hygiene items be provided to female inmates without charge
Stage Fast-Track
Comment Period Ended on 12/26/2018
spacer

37 comments

All comments for this forum
Back to List of Comments
11/26/18  9:57 am
Commenter: Shaheen Khurana, Virginia Menstrual Equity Coalition (VMEC)

HB83 Revised Regulation - Menstrual Equity in VA
 

Thank you for approving 6VAC 15-40-770, the HB83 revised regulation/standard!

I believe that access to safe menstrual products is a matter of human dignity and public health. Menstrual supplies are a health care necessity and not an item that can be foregone easily. Women are entitled to this basic right.... no matter their circumstances!!!

While passing this law has been a significant step forward in achieving menstrual equity, there must also be consistency and enforcement to ensure free and equal access to menstrual products across all jails and prisons.

Addressing the needs of women and girls must become a higher priority than it has been in the past. By passing this important legislation, VA is now on the leading edge of much needed change to achieve menstrual equity in the world and it will send a strong message of support to women that their needs matter. Tampons and pads should be provided freely, like toilet paper, in ALL public facilities.

 

 

CommentID: 68785
 

11/26/18  3:46 pm
Commenter: Mike Beaty

HB 83
 

Comment HB 83 .  It's not a need nor a want that women must have menstrual products for free.

I"m extend my full support support for menstrual equity in our jails and prisons.

Mike Beayty, Gainesville, VA 

 

 

CommentID: 68786
 

11/27/18  9:18 pm
Commenter: Katrin Patterson

Menstrual hygiene is dignity
 
Thank you so much for supporting the provision of menstrual hygiene products to incarcerated women, free of charge. This is the right thing to do, morally as well as logistically. Being able to discretely and effectively manage menstruation is important for personal as well as population health. Offering free menstrual products will no doubtedly improve the health, well-being, and cleanliness of the individuals and of the facilities they are housed in. Again, thank you for supporting this commonsense action.
CommentID: 68792
 

12/1/18  11:39 am
Commenter: Susan Laume

Menstral equity
 

Tampons and pads should be provided like toilet paper in public facilities and installations and jails for free. 

 

CommentID: 68807
 

12/1/18  1:50 pm
Commenter: Barbie Zabielski, MPH, New River Health District

in support of proposed changes to 6VAC15-40-770
 

Women in jails and prisons should be supplied with the basic items they need to maintain a reasonable degree of cleanliness and should not be charged a fee for it. Provision of tampons and pads as needed by each incarcerated individual should be part of the cost of incarcerating them, like costs associated with heating, toilet paper, and food. And it is important that tampons be provided to individuals in addition to sanitary pads. Besides the psychological distress many women feel at being forced to spend time sitting in their own blood, recognize that the environment within correctional institutions is rife with transmissible infections, and tampons are a means of reducing inmates’ exposure to one another’s blood. (Imagine stepping into a communal shower after someone with blood running down her legs because she was prohibited from using a tampon. This is simply unacceptable.) I urge you to implement the proposed changes immediately and thank you for fast-tracking this!

CommentID: 68808
 

12/2/18  1:18 pm
Commenter: Elizabeth Briggs

Menstrual Equality in Prisons
 

Providing female inmates the menstrual products they prefer at no charge is simply common sense and humane.

CommentID: 68816
 

12/2/18  1:23 pm
Commenter: Thuja Jameson

Support for changes - Virginia should provide inmates menstrual products
 

I write to support the proposed changes that would provide access to the menstrual products needed by inmates.  Thank you.

CommentID: 68817
 

12/2/18  5:22 pm
Commenter: Lyn Day

Provision of hygiene items
 

I I approve of the proosed changes regarding hygiene items for women.

CommentID: 68820
 

12/2/18  5:32 pm
Commenter: Michelle Wilkins

Menstrual supplies for female inmates
 
I am 100% in favor of the proposed language changes for menstrual supplies to be provided to female inmates. For women, proper menstrual hygiene not only affects your health but also your sense of humanity. It is equal to providing toilet paper. Women nearing menopause may also be experiencing extremely heavy flow and the availability of supplies may be higher for them so the "upon request" is important.
CommentID: 68821
 

12/2/18  6:00 pm
Commenter: Katherine Randall

Agency in menstrual hygiene
 

I support the proposed changes in the regulation language. People should be allowed to choose the menstrual hygiene product that works best for them; letting a facility define and determine what will be considered and distributed as a menstrual hygiene product neglects the individual bodies and needs of menstrual product users. Additionally, the provision that products will be provided "without charge" is crucial. Having a period is not a choice. Those with already limited financial resources, like those incarcerated, should not be financially punished for biological functions. Should we charge an inmate for the use of toilet paper? 

Regarding the striking of the word "reasonable" from the provision, this change is, again, necessary to recognize the individual needs of menstrual product users. Menstrual cycles, flows, and needs vary widely. It should never be up to another person to determine what is a "reasonable" request for menstrual products. 

CommentID: 68823
 

12/2/18  6:03 pm
Commenter: Ted Parent, Ph.D., Virginia Tech

All Men Must Support This Too.
 

It can be easy for most men to ignore this sort of issue, since we don't have to deal with this aspect of hygiene. But for one, we all know that blood can be a biohazard, and it is important to keep things sanitary. More than that, however, it is a humanitarian issue. If innmates were not provided with general first-aid supplies on demand, for instance, it would clearly be baseless and needlessly dehumanizing. Both in the interest of public health, and on moral grounds, this change should be given full support.

CommentID: 68824
 

12/2/18  7:49 pm
Commenter: Nicolaus Tideman

A Valuable Change
 

The proposed change in the regulations is very valuable. Women who are incarcerated should not be burdened with worry about where they will get the feminine hygene supplies that they need.

CommentID: 68828
 

12/3/18  11:36 am
Commenter: J. Pixley Great Expectations Coach

support change in language of regulation re: feminine hygiene products
 

i am in supoort of 6VAC15-40-770, a provision which includes providing and allowing the use of tampons for feminine hygiene for incarcertated women.  This change would provide more santiary conditions for all and reduce exposure to blood born pathogens that may be associated with menstruation flow that may be unchecked or not properly contained.  

CommentID: 68838
 

12/3/18  4:23 pm
Commenter: Amanda Talbert RN

100% agree with this change
 

I am in total agreeance with this change. All women should be allowed to have these supplies on request at anytime. Not only is this a moral issue but also a health risk when they are not able to have these supplies.

CommentID: 68840
 

12/6/18  12:42 pm
Commenter: Kemp Barber, undergrad student at Virginia tech

This should be a no brainer.
 

ALL women deserve hygienic methods of dealing with their own biological processes, and making these NEEDS unavailable and ternate options potentially punishable is an egregious injustice by the State. Make it happen. Incarceration should not strip people of their humanity to this extent. Do right by these women, we demand it. 

CommentID: 68848
 

12/6/18  2:00 pm
Commenter: Bailey Villarreal

Proposed changes to legislation
 

The proposed changes to this legislation must happen. This is not a complicated decision and we shouldn’t insult our intelligence by pretending that it is. All we need to be is compassionate, inquisitive, and understanding. 

CommentID: 68850
 

12/6/18  2:04 pm
Commenter: Seth Peters

Recognition of basic human decency
 
As per my title, these changes give female prisoners back their basic human decency. No prisoner should have to live as some have had to. Also, here's a comment another poster put that I feel is very correct: ALL women deserve hygienic methods of dealing with their own biological processes, and making these NEEDS unavailable and ternate options potentially punishable is an egregious injustice by the State. Make it happen. Incarceration should not strip people of their humanity to this extent. Do right by these women, we demand it.
CommentID: 68851
 

12/9/18  10:12 pm
Commenter: Catherine Read, BRAWS HB 83 Accountability Committee

Meeting the Basic Human Needs of Inmates
 

This is an important regulation that gives dignity to all those who are incarcerated and menstruate. This is a normal bodily function and should be treated in the same way we provide toilet paper in all places where there are toilets. The fact that the basic needs of menstruating inmates has been subject to arbitrary decision making on the part of corrections facilities and the employees of those facilities is quite frankly archaic. Just because someone is incarcerated doesn't justify arbitrarily denying them basic necessitites. 

Tampons better meet the needs of many menstruating inmates and up to this point those were only available by purchase. Here in the 21st century, providing tampons free of charge in addition to pads is not something that should even be up for discussion.

I hope that this regulation passes without delay and it's implementation is a priority. The DOC and the Office of Public Safety need to communicate this policy clearly, promote its adoption immedaitely, and put in place a plan to make certain it is being implemented effectively. 

CommentID: 68865
 

12/10/18  8:40 pm
Commenter: Noah Rothenburger

Basic Human Decency
 

The propsed change to the legislation is a good thing and should be supported. Basic cleanliness is a must for any population that does not want disease to run rampant, especially with a vector as potent as blood. In addition, the cost should be covered by the prison, as these items are needed by the women to help control a natural cycle that they themselves have no power over. It is in basic human decency to give these women the necessary items for personal hygiene. 

CommentID: 68870
 

12/12/18  1:27 am
Commenter: Brooke Plotnick, concerned voter

Sanitary Supplies for inmates
 
I enthusiastically support providing free sanitary supplies in all bathrooms: prisons, public buildings, museums, libraries, and schools. These are as basic and necessary as toilet paper and should be treated in the same manner: as a need. Thank you for righting this wrong.
CommentID: 68874
 

12/12/18  10:28 am
Commenter: Larry Mendoza, State Director: American Atheists

American Atheists supports supplying women with sanitary products. Not doing so is discriminatory.
 

My organization supports any legislation that will remove any discriminatory practices across Virginia.  It is basic human decency to give women the proper care they deserve, even in prison.  By not providing the needed sanitary products, sets up a discriminatory practice that targets a specific group of inmates, specifically women.  This needs to stop and it needs to change. This is a women's rights issue that needs to be addressed immediately. 

We support this change whole heartedly.

Larry Mendoza, MS

CommentID: 68876
 

12/12/18  10:53 am
Commenter: Paul MacDonald

Not accommodating the reasonable needs of prisoners is cruel.
 

Please consider providing, free of charge, feminine hygeine products to mensturating females everywhere in the Virginia penal system.  Anything less is inhumane.

CommentID: 68877
 

12/12/18  11:30 am
Commenter: Elizabeth Florek

I use about six super-absorptive tampons a month.
 

And I have a fairly light period, actually. Mine lasts about four days- I use two or three tampons the first day, two the second day, and two more over the next two-three days. 

Think I just told you too much information? First of all, grow up. Second of all, forcing prisoners to disclose how many menstrual products they need a month and denying them access to menstrual supplies if they go over their ‘limit’ is absurdly similar to what I just shared with you. Sorry, folks, but we’re not bleeding AT you. Going over the ‘limit’ for menstrual supplies isn’t an act of defiance- it’s an involuntary act of bloody uterine tissue as affected by gravity. Want to argue with gravity that it’s pulling too much blood out of us and messing up the internal prison menstrual supply estimates? Go right ahead- but please, videotape it, because I could use a laugh.

I just finished my period yesterday so I’m going to go pull out and flush my last tampon now. That’s the sixth one I’ve used. However, just because my period comes like clockwork doesn’t mean that others are blessed with a consistent period. If someone needs more menstrual supplies than they did last month, do yourself and your floors a favor and just give them more supplies. Thanks for reading!

CommentID: 68878
 

12/12/18  11:39 am
Commenter: Michelle Jesse

Provide sanitary supplies to these women
 
The level of greed and lack of empathy needed to deny women free sanitary items is absolutely shameful. Change this policy now!
CommentID: 68879
 

12/12/18  7:11 pm
Commenter: Matthew DeGrave

I support providing providing free feminine hygiene products to women in prison
 
This change will provide feminine hygiene products to women in prison that may not be able to afford the products otherwise
CommentID: 68884
 

12/13/18  12:00 pm
Commenter: Rebekah Turk

Free feminine hygiene products
 

I support the changes to provide free sanitary napkins and tampons to female inmates. 

CommentID: 68889
 

12/13/18  4:56 pm
Commenter: Debbie Rowe

Menstrual Equity
 

Menstrual products should be available for free in all Jails and Prisons just like toilet paper.  It is both a moral and a sanitary issue. Thank you for fast-tracking!

CommentID: 68891
 

12/15/18  3:21 pm
Commenter: Del Kaye Kory

HB83
 

Incarcerated women desreve to be treated with dignity--this is an important step towards that goal. 

CommentID: 68906
 

12/18/18  1:05 pm
Commenter: Terry Stevens

HB83
 

It is surprising that women in prisons are not given feminine hygiene products as needed each month. So - yes, please pass this bill.

CommentID: 68914
 

12/20/18  10:18 am
Commenter: Rev. Pamela Philips

Support Dignity and Equity
 

My faith calls me to affirm and promote the inherent worth and dignity of all people. Denying women the tampons and sanitary napkins they require during their menstrual period denies their worth and dignity. Making them pay for these supplies denies them equity. I fully support the amendment to 6VAC15-40-770.

CommentID: 68924
 

12/20/18  2:15 pm
Commenter: Her Padded Truth®?

Menstrual Equality
 

As a woman who has access to menstruated hygiene products I feel compelled to write on behalf of those who do not have the “luxury” (no pun intended) to have constant access to menstrual hygiene products that are free. As a Nurse Practitioner I see the rashes, infections, and deaths that proceed the use of unsafe products to catch our monthly flows used by women who are incarcerated. I believe that menstrual health is a vital part of our health and having access to free products is a must. Image sitting in one place, embarrassed to love because you have spoiled yourself and don’t have access to a pad or additional tampon. Many women suffer from heavy flows and need extra absorbency. Women who are incarcerated should not have to beg and plead for the essential needs. I am for the revision!

CommentID: 68926
 

12/20/18  3:34 pm
Commenter: Sara Holtz, DrPH

human dignity & public health imperative
 

Imagine your mother, sister, daughter, aunt, cousin or friend with no means at her disposal to catch her monthly bleeding. Then consider the public health impact of that blood on anyone who might unknowingly come in contact with it. Making tampons and pads available is imperative.

 

CommentID: 68927
 

12/20/18  8:00 pm
Commenter: Laura Nelson

100% support for 6VAC15-40-770. Provision of hygiene items
 

It is not only common decency to provide basic hygienic care products (toothbrush/paste/sanitary napkins/tampons) but it is a health concern not to. I am in complete support of this provision of hygiene items for incarcerated women. 

CommentID: 68928
 

12/20/18  8:26 pm
Commenter: David Roberts, MD

100% Support for proposed changes
 

I am a Gynecologist. Mensrual bleeding is obviously something completely foreign to men. Over the past 28 years, I have heard hundreds of stories relating to the inadequate management of menstrual bleeding. Few things are more embarrassing than bleeding through one’s garments. Incarcerated women need access to feminine hygiene products and they shouldn’t have to jump through humiliating hoops to get them. 

CommentID: 68929
 

12/21/18  3:25 pm
Commenter: Sheeba Bruning

Menstrual Equality
 
This is not a matter of a need or a want. All women should have access to menstrual hygiene products. I extend my full support for menstrual equality.
CommentID: 68930
 

12/23/18  12:28 pm
Commenter: Phyllis Turk, CNM

Menstrual hygiene
 

Thank you for approving 6VAC 1-40-770, the revised regulation/standard.                                                              As a registered nurse and nurse midwife I am very familiar with women's health and hygiene needs related to menstruation. Access to appropriate menstrual products is a health and public health issue particuarly for incarcerated women. Tampons and sanitary pads should be available without charge and readily accessible for all inmates who need them.                                                                                                                                            By passing this legislation with the revised regulations Virginia's leadership has demonstrated an awareness that women's health needs do matter.  I hope this new standard will be consistently enforced in all the jails and prisons throughout the Commonwealth.

CommentID: 68933
 

12/26/18  11:40 am
Commenter: Catherine Gruber

Menstrual Equity should include tampons
 

Thank you for approving 6VAC 15-40-770, the HB83 revised regulation/standard.

Access to safe menstrual products is a matter of human dignity and public health, and menstrual supplies are a health care necessity. That includes tampons and pads, which should be provided freely, like toilet paper, in ALL public facilities. Consistency and enforcement are essential to ensure free and equal access to menstrual products across all jails and prisons.

CommentID: 68935